Last Updated: 6/28/2026
Paying:
- $0.03 per base card
- $0.10 per insert/parallel
- $2 per relic card
Important Notes:
NOT BUYING Topps BIG, jumbos, minis, cards with water damage or mold, and chrome cards covered in powder. Please keep all of this stuff out of the lot. Thank you.
- For Frank Thomas, minis and jumbos okay
- Inserts includes parallels
- Condition flexible, but cards must be fully intact
Baseball Cards:
To keep it simple, the total list is broken up into two separate lists:
1. Buying everything of these players:
| Last Name | First Name |
|---|---|
| Alomar | Roberto |
| Arenado | Nolan |
| Bagwell | Jeff |
| Baines | Harold |
| Belle | Albert |
| Beltran | Carlos |
| Beltre | Adrian |
| Bench | Johnny |
| Betts | Mookie |
| Biggio | Craig |
| Blyleven | Bert |
| Boggs | Wade |
| Bonds | Barry |
| Brett | George |
| Brock | Lou |
| Cabrera | Miguel |
| Canseco | Jose |
| Carew | Rod |
| Carlton | Steve |
| Carter | Gary |
| Clark | Will |
| Clemens | Roger |
| Cole | Gerrit |
| Dawson | Andre |
| Eckersley | Dennis |
| Fisk | Carlton |
| Garciaparra | Nomar |
| Garvey | Steve |
| Glavine | Tom |
| Goldschmidt | Paul |
| Gonzalez | Juan |
| Greinke | Zack |
| Griffey Jr. | Ken |
| Guerrero (Sr.) | Vladimir |
| Gwynn | Tony |
| Harper | Bryce |
| Helton | Todd |
| Henderson | Rickey |
| Hernandez | Keith |
| Heyward | Jason |
| Jackson | Bo |
| Jackson | Reggie |
| Jenkins | Fergie |
| Jeter | Derek |
| John | Tommy |
| Johnson | Randy |
| Jones | Andruw |
| Jones | Chipper |
| Jordan | Michael |
| Judge | Aaron |
| Kaat | Jim |
| Kershaw | Clayton |
| Larkin | Barry |
| Lofton | Kenny |
| Maddux | Greg |
| Martinez | Edgar |
| Martinez | Pedro |
| Mattingly | Don |
| Mauer | Joe |
| McCovey | Willie |
| McGriff | Fred |
| McGwire | Mark |
| Molina | Yadier |
| Molitor | Paul |
| Morgan | Joe |
| Morris | Jack |
| Murray | Eddie |
| Mussina | Mike |
| Niekro | Phil |
| Nomo | Hideo |
| Palmer | Jim |
| Parker | Dave |
| Perry | Gaylord |
| Piazza | Mike |
| Posey | Buster |
| Puckett | Kirby |
| Pujols | Albert |
| Ramirez | Manny |
| Ripken Jr. | Cal |
| Rivera | Mariano |
| Robinson | Brooks |
| Robinson | Frank |
| Rodriguez | Alex |
| Rodriguez | Ivan |
| Rolen | Scott |
| Rose | Pete |
| Ryan | Nolan |
| Sabathia | C.C. |
| Sandberg | Ryne |
| Seaver | Tom |
| Sheffield | Gary |
| Scherzer | Max |
| Schilling | Curt |
| Schmidt | Mike |
| Smith | Lee |
| Smith | Ozzie |
| Smoltz | John |
| Sosa | Sammy |
| Soto | Juan |
| Strasburg | Stephen |
| Sutter | Bruce |
| Sutton | Don |
| Suzuki | Ichiro |
| Thomas | Frank |
| Thome | Jim |
| Trammell | Alan |
| Trout | Mike |
| Verlander | Justin |
| Votto | Joey |
| Wagner | Billy |
| Walker | Larry |
| Winfield | Dave |
| Yastrzemski | Carl |
| Yount | Robin |
2. Buying only rookie era and inserts of these players:
| Last Name | First Name |
|---|---|
| Abbott | Jim |
| Alomar Jr. | Sandy |
| Bonilla | Bobby |
| Carter | Joe |
| Fielder | Cecil |
| Galarraga | Andres |
| Gant | Ron |
| Grace | Mark |
| Hoskins | Rhys |
| Kruk | John |
| Lee | Travis |
| Machado | Manny |
| Martinez | Tino |
| O’Neill | Paul |
| Palmeiro | Rafael |
| Ramirez (Indians) | Jose |
| Salmon | Tim |
| Santiago | Benito |
| Strawberry | Darryl |
| Turner | Trea |
| Valenzuela | Fernando |
| Vaughn | Mo |
| Ventura | Robin |
| Viola | Frank |
| Whitaker | Lou |
| Williams | Matt |
| Wilson | Willie |
| Wood | Kerry |
| Yelich | Christian |