Jordan Red PMG or Kobe Refractor? Collectors Weigh In on Which Card they would Prefer to Own

Kobe Bryant 1996-97 Topps Chrome Refractor | Michael Jordan 1997-98 Metal Universe Precious Metal Gems (PMG) Red

These are two of the most desirable basketball cards in the hobby. For what they are and their associated grades, they make for an excellent comparison. Both of these cards sold in close proximity of each other. Here's the sales data:

Kobe Bryant 1996-97 Topps Chrome Refractor BGS 10

  • Sold: Feb 28, 2019
  • # of Bids: 94
  • Final Price: $62,600

1996-97 Topps Chrome is a 220-card set and released exclusively via retail, which means production and availability was limited. Packs carried a $2.99 SRP and came with 4 cards. Refractors were inserted at a rate of 1:12. Aside from card #72, to denote their status, all refractors have an "R" next to the card number. The Kobe Bryant is the most notable card in the set.

Shop for 1996-97 Topps Chrome Refractors on eBay

Michael Jordan 1997-98 Metal Universe Precious Metal Gems Red PSA 6.5

  • Sold: Mar 20, 2019
  • # of Bids: 54
  • Final Price: $63,100

1997-98 Metal Universe Precious Metal Gems are serial numbered to 100 and parallel the 123-card base set. Serial numbers 1-10 are the Emerald PMGs while serial numbers 11-100 are the Red PMGs. That said, Emeralds carry a print run of 10 copies while Reds carry a print run of 90 copies. The Michael Jordan, in any version, is the most valuable card of them all.

Shop for 1997-98 Metal Universe Precious Metal Gems on eBay

→ Related article: This Michael Jordan 1997-98 Metal Universe PMG Closed at Over $350k

These two sales got me thinking which of these two cards would collectors rather have so I did some market research with a 1Q poll asking the following question:

Which would you rather have?

Survey Makeup:

  • Ran from April 3-5, 2019
  • Marketed on Twitter, Facebook Groups, and Community Forums
  • # of Responses Collected: 48

Survey Results:

The survey started off collecting significantly more votes for Jordan than Kobe but as time went on, the data began to normalize. When the poll closed, votes were places heavily in Jordans favor, which tells us a few things:

  • Michael Jordan cards are much more desirable than Kobe Bryant cards, at least at the time of this poll
  • Michael Jordan continues to outperform some of the strongest of comparison candidates in terms of investment potential and collectibility
  • While Kobe Bryant's most valuable rookie card draws significant attention, it's still not as desirable as a rare Michael Jordan parallel from the same decade
  • In this grade, this Kobe Bryant rookie card is one of, if not the most valuable of all basketball rookie cards of the 1990s

Have something to share? Post your thoughts in the comments area.

2006 07 Topps Chrome 1996 97 Variations Black Refractor 99 180 Andrea Bargnani
2006 07 Topps Chrome 1996 97 Variations Black Refractor 99 180 Andrea Bargnani
$21.78
KEVIN GARNETT 1996 TOPPS CHROME REFRACTOR 131 PSA 7 NM
KEVIN GARNETT 1996 TOPPS CHROME REFRACTOR 131 PSA 7 NM
$41.00
1996 Topps Chrome Kerry Kittles Refractor Psa 9
1996 Topps Chrome Kerry Kittles Refractor Psa 9
$50.00
1996 Topps Chrome Scottie Pippen REFRACTOR
1996 Topps Chrome Scottie Pippen REFRACTOR
$60.00
1996 97 Topps Chrome Refractor 191 Jermaine ONeal PSA 9
1996 97 Topps Chrome Refractor 191 Jermaine ONeal PSA 9
$72.50
1996 Topps Chrome Refractor Kobe Bryant ROOKIE RC PSA 10  Jeter 1993 SP Foil
1996 Topps Chrome Refractor Kobe Bryant ROOKIE RC PSA 10 Jeter 1993 SP Foil
$39,999.99
1996 Topps Chrome Refractor 29 Sam Perkins Detroit Pistons Seattle Supersonics
1996 Topps Chrome Refractor 29 Sam Perkins Detroit Pistons Seattle Supersonics
$27.53
1996 97 Topps Chrome Refractor 107 Sean Elliott San Antonio Spurs Card
1996 97 Topps Chrome Refractor 107 Sean Elliott San Antonio Spurs Card
$10.57
1996 97 Topps Chrome Refractor 59 Reggie Williams Denver Nuggets Card
1996 97 Topps Chrome Refractor 59 Reggie Williams Denver Nuggets Card
$14.87
JERMAINE ONEAL CHROME RC 191 PSA GEM MINT 10  SP RC REFRACTOR PSA MINT 9
JERMAINE ONEAL CHROME RC 191 PSA GEM MINT 10 SP RC REFRACTOR PSA MINT 9
$120.99
2006 Topps Chrome 1996 97 Variations Black Refractor 99 195 Adam Morrison Card
2006 Topps Chrome 1996 97 Variations Black Refractor 99 195 Adam Morrison Card
$21.78
1996 97 TOPPS CHROME REFRACTOR GRANT HILL 100 SHARP
1996 97 TOPPS CHROME REFRACTOR GRANT HILL 100 SHARP
$54.99
1996 97 Topps Chrome Refractor 26 Mark Bryant Golden State Warriors Card
1996 97 Topps Chrome Refractor 26 Mark Bryant Golden State Warriors Card
$14.82
1996 Topps Chrome Refractor Allen Iverson ROOKIE RC 171 PSA 9 MINT PWCC
1996 Topps Chrome Refractor Allen Iverson ROOKIE RC 171 PSA 9 MINT PWCC
$1,175.00
1996 Topps Chrome Refractor Steve Nash ROOKIE RC 182 BGS 9 MINT PWCC
1996 Topps Chrome Refractor Steve Nash ROOKIE RC 182 BGS 9 MINT PWCC
$368.00
1996 Topps Chrome Refractor Ray Allen ROOKIE RC 217 PSA 9 MINT PWCC
1996 Topps Chrome Refractor Ray Allen ROOKIE RC 217 PSA 9 MINT PWCC
$300.00

« Previous1234567

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.